Étienne Balibar, Palestine, facing genocide, followed by The Antisemitism and Its Doubles. Divergences Editions, 11/09/2026. 180 pages, €17
Étienne Balibar seeks, through the works Palestine, facing genocide and its companion The Antisemitism and Its Doubles, to redraw the boundaries, dismantle the conventional oppositions, and reintroduce reflective thought where political passions threaten to reduce everything to irreconcilable confrontations. In a context shaped by the massacres of October 7, 2023, the devastating war in Gaza, the crisis of international law, and the resurgence of antisemitism, the author offers a meditation that extends well beyond the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. It is more an interrogation of humanity, universalism, justice, and the political responsibilities of our era. A philosopher of contemporary political thought and a former student of Louis Althusser, Balibar has devoted his work to democracy, borders, the relations between nation and citizenship, as well as the mechanisms of domination and exclusion. He mobilizes this theoretical heritage to confront a tragedy that, in his view, represents a major test for the international political conscience.
Palestine, a Question That Concerns All of Humanity
The first text begins from a fundamental conviction: the Palestinian cause cannot be treated as a regional issue, much less as a mere territorial dispute between two populations. It engages the very principles on which modern democracies purport to stand: equal rights, human dignity, self-determination of peoples, and the universality of law. The author refuses to confine the Palestinian question to militant solidarity or to an ideological opposition between Israel and its adversaries. He restores to it a universal dimension. What happens in Gaza touches our conception of justice, our relation to violence, and our ability to recognize the humanity of those whose history and affiliations we do not share. He does not seek to erase the events of October 7, 2023, nor the responsibility of the terrorist organizations that carried out the massacres and took hostages. Nevertheless, he rejects granting those crimes an unlimited license to justify violence against the Palestinian population. The distinction between fighting terrorism and protecting civilians is essential here.
By labeling the destruction of Gaza as genocide, Étienne Balibar adopts a clear political and intellectual stance. This qualification sits within a legal and international controversy that requires careful attention to the facts, intentions, and decisions of competent jurisdictions. Beyond the debate over terminology, his inquiry asks a fundamental question: how far can a society go in exercising its military power without losing the principles of justice and humanity that it claims to defend?
Universalism Put to the Test by Its Contradictions
The philosopher confirms that universalism cannot be merely a moral proclamation. It must be tested in concrete situations where the rights of some appear at risk of being sacrificed for the sake of others’ security. He highlights a major contradiction of our era: the solemn assertion of human rights coexists with a substantial tolerance for their violation. International law, humanitarian conventions, and the protection of civilians cannot be invoked with variable geometry. This reflection ties into Balibar’s earlier work on the concept of “egaliberty,” which links equality and liberty inseparably. True freedom cannot exist without the fundamental equality of persons. When applied to Palestine and Israel, this requirement leads to rejecting any political organization that makes enduring inequality between populations a condition for its own existence. This approach helps move beyond solidarities grounded solely in identity. Defending the Palestinians does not mean denying the rights of Israelis. Acknowledging Israeli suffering must not, in turn, erase Palestinian suffering. Universalism begins precisely when we refuse to rank human lives.
Antisemitism and Its Doubles: An indispensable reflection
The second text, The Antisemitism and Its Doubles, is arguably the most delicate and thought-provoking portion of the book. Balibar examines contemporary transformations of antisemitism, as well as the political uses that can be made of its denunciation. This is not an attempt to relativize the persistence of Jew-hatred or to minimize its manifestations. Antisemitism remains a historical and present reality that must be fought without ambiguity. Yet the philosopher warns against the confusions and instrumentalizations that can arise when any critique of Israeli policy is equated with antisemitism. Such a mix threatens both the freedom of democratic debate and the very comprehension of antisemitism. Two requirements must be held together: never use the fight against antisemitism to automatically disqualify criticism of Israel; never use criticism of Israel to trivialize antisemitic prejudices, conspiracy theories, or both old and new forms of hatred toward Jews.
The plural in the title is implicit. It invites reflection on the mechanisms of substitution, displacement, and reproduction of prejudices. The author also questions how contemporary conflicts fit into a genuine “war of civilizations,” where religious, national, and cultural identities become instruments of political mobilization. This reflection is important for the European left. It must be able to defend Palestinian rights without reproducing—even unintentionally—antisemitic representations inherited from its history. It must also be able to combat antisemitism without renouncing its critique of nationalist policies and power relationships.
The Memory of the Shoah and Political Responsibility
Another thread running through these two texts is memory. The Shoah represents a foundational historical experience, whose singularity and significance cannot be relativized. It has profoundly shaped European consciousness and our understanding of collective responsibility. The memory of persecutions should not become a tool to shield state policy from critical scrutiny. The history of victims cannot grant a perpetual right to power, nor should it justify forgetting today’s victims.
This reflection is especially sensitive because it touches Jewish identity, family and collective memory, as well as Israel’s place in contemporary political history. Balibar invites us to distinguish acknowledging the Jewish people, fighting antisemitism, the right of Israelis to live securely, and adherence to the government’s decisions. These realities do not merge. To separate them is not to weaken solidarity with Jews; rather, it preserves the possibility of a free and responsible political thought.
A Demanding, Sometimes Uncomfortable, Yet Necessary Essay
Reading this book is not always easy. Balibar’s conceptual density, philosophical vocabulary, and historical references assume a certain familiarity with contemporary political thought. The relatively concise format of the volume may leave readers wanting more: some historical and geopolitical questions would benefit from deeper development. It does not seek to produce a comfortable consensus. It compels readers to think together about realities that public debate often opposes. It rejects identitarian labels, selective solidarities, and ideological simplifications.
These two texts are inseparable. The first reaffirms the universal demand for justice in the face of the Palestinian catastrophe; the second warns against politically instrumental uses of memory and the fight against antisemitism. Their true unity lies in a deeply humanistic conviction: no political cause, no collective memory, no national claim can legitimately be built on denying the humanity of others. They pose, each in their own way, a fundamental question: how to conceive a Jewish identity that is not confined within an exclusive communal logic, nor instrumentalized by state power? In a time when societies fracture, memories clash, and words themselves become weapons, Étienne Balibar reminds us that universalism is neither abstraction nor moral posture. It is a political imperative, a responsibility, and a struggle.
This book invites us to defend, at once, justice for the Palestinians, security for Israelis, an unconditional fight against antisemitism, and the possibility of a shared future. The defense of humanity cannot be variable geometry, and because no durable peace can arise from the negation of the other.
The article Palestine, facing genocide, an essay on universal justice appeared first on Lythrum Press.