Education Decree and Digital Textbooks: FdI Amendment Passes; Publishers Warn Paperless Learning

21 November 2026

The obligation on publishers to provide textbooks for students in a printable digital version at 50% of the cover price of the corresponding print edition continues to spark debate and divide the ruling majority.

As we noted, after protests from publishers, in early November the provision within the Budget Bill at Article 105 was stricken, but the measure later returned to the agenda with an amendment from Fratelli d’Italia, which drew the opposition of Forza Italia.

Forza Italia votes against (with the opposition), yet the amendment passes

Before today’s clash in the Senate chamber, Forza Italia had already voted in committee against the Bucalo-Fallucchi amendment regarding 50% discounted school ebooks proposed by FdI. The Azurri party thus sided with the centre-left.

Then, in the Senate as well, the majority fractured: Forza Italia voted with the opposition against Fratelli d’Italia’s amendment.

In the end, the Senate chamber approved it with 84 yes, 76 no and 1 abstention. Azione voted with the centre-right, and, according to Repubblica.it, the opposition paid for the absence of about ten senators.

Cipolletta (AIE): “Learning and true opportunity to learn come from paper books”

The president of the Italian Publishers Association, Innocenzo Cipolletta, who from the outset had criticized the measure (“It introduces, without any prior discussion, a provision that harms publishers, booksellers, authors and which is constructed in complete disregard for the category of educational and academic publishers and for copyright, for the rightful remuneration due for the intellectual work of those who write, explain, lay out, update and edit such texts and whose value and the costs of development – we reiterate this even if it should be obvious – are not solely those of the paper on which they are printed”), told Corriere della Sera, on the eve of the Senate vote, that the measure “doesn’t work because, first, in a free-market system a government mandate forcing production of a product at a predetermined price, limited to a single sector, would be simply scandalous.” Second, it doesn’t work for families… A printable digital book that is only partially so would inevitably lead to poor learning”.

And further: “We are talking about a remarkable convenience tool, but as is now clear to everyone in Europe, study and real learning come from paper books. Even the Northern European countries that leaned on the so‑called ‘all digital’ approach are reversing course and returning to traditional books: comprehension results have been disastrous and alarming, and so the course has been reversed; simply inform yourself. Therefore pushing for ‘digital-only’ purchases will mean learning little and badly.”

The editors’ hot take: “A measure that does not solve the problem of textbook costs”

Immediately after the Senate vote, Cipolletta commented: “A measure that does not solve the cost problem for families and students, promotes the spread of piracy that the Government claims to fight, but shifts the burden of a policy of support onto the education and scholarly publishing sector, which should be a public responsibility. Such a rule affecting copyright alters the economic value of the work and jeopardizes the sustainability of a sector essential to the quality of education in our country. We are deeply concerned and we will resist this measure in every possible way and in every arena.”

“It is a measure that risks grave consequences for the entire chain,” continued the president of AIE. “The value of a textbook is not equal to the cost of the paper it is printed on: it includes the intellectual labor of authors, illustrators, editors and curators, investments in design, updating and content innovation, as well as validation and distribution. Imposing by law that the content be worth half simply because it is consumed in a digital format means denying the value of the creative and editorial work that produced it. It also sets a very serious precedent for intellectual property protection and for the constitutional guarantee of economic freedom in business, which must be carefully weighed against national and European law.”

“Even more worrying is the cultural message this choice could send. Schools and universities need high-quality books with reliable, up-to-date content that is continually improved. If we truly want to help families and ensure universal access to study, public tools to support textbook purchases should be strengthened, not the value of the work of those who write, produce and update these books should be devalued by law. With this rule the future of educational and academic publishing is at stake, but so is the quality of the tools through which we shape the next generations.”

The booksellers’ stance: “The consequences are, unfortunately, very heavy”

The Associazione Librai Italiani Confcommercio also acknowledges the parliamentary approval of the rule requiring publishers to make school and university textbooks available in a fully printable digital version at half the price of the corresponding paper edition: “Every parliamentary vote outcome must be respected, and we can only take note of the choice made. To take note, however, does not mean to share it, nor to deem it the right solution for students and families, especially given the consequences that will fall on the entire book supply chain.

This measure does not solve textbook costs for families but shifts responsibility onto publishing firms and the supply chain, with the risk of encouraging illegal reproduction and diffusion of content. ALI Confcommercio has been proposing for years that textbook purchases be tax-deductible, like medical expenses: education and health are two pillars of the State’s commitments to citizens. In addition, the fund for the right to study should be strengthened, not reduced, especially now when poverty and financial difficulties have risen. The consequences for bookstores and our sector’s businesses will be very heavy. But our concern also concerns the future of the textbook. A book is not merely a support, but a tool that selects, organizes and links knowledge, building coherent learning paths. The risk is that it will gradually be replaced by a fragmented and disjointed set of digital contents, losing its role in transmitting and disseminating knowledge.” ALI Confcommercio adds: “This is not about defending the past or opposing technological innovation, but about ensuring that choices made without proper assessment of consequences do not compromise the quality of learning. The experiences of other countries that have adopted similar solutions should have urged greater caution. ALI Confcommercio welcomes the adoption of the order of the day calling on the Government to set up a national roundtable to discuss the law’s impacts. We hope this will not stay a symbolic commitment but will quickly translate into concrete dialogue with all the players in the supply chain.”

“To Italian booksellers,” declares ALI Confcommercio president Paolo Ambrosini, “I pledge the Association’s full commitment to facing the changes and difficulties this law will bring to our businesses. We will not shirklike away from our responsibilities and we will work to defend the sector. Yet there is a question that concerns everyone: what idea of knowledge and education do we want to pass on to the new generations? Innovation is not a value in itself: progress is measured by improving the quality of learning, not merely by replacing one tool with another.”

International publishers also weigh in

European and international publishers likewise urge the Italian government to reconsider the bill proposing a compulsory 50% discount on digital versions of textbooks intended for schools and universities.

Gvantsa Jobava, president of the International Publishers Association (IPA), explained: “This new law is another example of how governments restrict the editing freedom in the educational publishing sector. As highlighted in our latest Report published earlier this year, editorial freedom is not only curtailed by censorship but also eroded by the economic conditions necessary for publication itself.”

Phaedon Kidoniatis, president of the Federation of European Publishers (FEP), added: “Italy’s demand to provide digital versions of paper textbooks at 50% off, with the extra condition that 15% of that digital file can be printed, constitutes a new exception to copyright law in conflict with the three-step test. EU law requires that exceptions not clash with the normal exploitation of the work, which will certainly occur in this case. The FEP hopes common sense will prevail and that the bill will be withdrawn.”

Christoph Pienkoss, chairman of the Educational Publishers Forum of the IPA, stated: “The Italian government’s proposal is counterproductive and would represent a setback for Italian education. The benefits of digital learning tools and learning resources are widely recognized. Meanwhile, schools, teachers and progressive educational policies acknowledge that a blend of printed materials and properly chosen digital resources from educational publishers best equips students to develop core skills (reading, writing, arithmetic). All-digital policies became obsolete years ago. The education system relies on up-to-date instructional resources provided by publishers. The government’s intervention would weaken publishers’ ability and incentives to innovate and to deliver high-quality resources for teachers and students in the future. Italian educational policy is hindering the progress of student learning in Italy without a valid reason.”

ARTICLE BEING UPDATED…

Amelia Hartwell

I write about books the way I read them: slowly, curiously, and with attention to the details that linger after the final page. At Lythrum Press, I cover literary fiction, essays, memoirs and the wider culture of reading, with a particular interest in voices that challenge familiar ways of seeing the world. My work is guided by one simple idea: a good book deserves more than a reaction — it deserves a conversation.