“H ow do you know about this waterfall?” I asked Lyla as she weaved a path through the trees.
“I came up here a couple times in high school.” She slowed, looking to her left, then right, before continuing straight.
From how often she stopped to spin in a slow circle, I was fairly certain she was lost. But I had a good idea of where we were—countless hours studying local maps had been time well spent.
If she got turned around, I’d be able to find our way back to the truck. So I let her keep going, my gaze alternating between the forest and her sweet, delicious ass.
I’d been fighting a hard-on ever since she’d taken the lead. Not exactly what I should be focused on today. But Lyla needed this hike. She hadn’t said anything, I just had a hunch.
Today was more about her getting a piece of herself back than tracking Cormac.
More time well spent.
“I had this boyfriend my junior year who loved to hike. He was a year older and spent a lot of time hiking in these mountains. He found this waterfall and brought me along.” She glanced over her shoulder, a shy smile on her mouth as she dramatically pressed her hand to her heart. “I thought it was so romantic, him discovering this waterfall just for me.”
So this was a hookup spot. A spear of jealousy shot through my chest, in one side and out the other.
Lyla faced forward before she could see my jaw clench. For fuck’s sake.
Jealous of a high school boyfriend. What the hell was happening to me? I couldn’t remember the last time I’d been jealous. None of Tiff’s past lovers had irritated me. Hell, she worked with an ex, and I hadn’t cared— maybe they’d get back together now. Good for them.
So why did just the mention of Lyla’s former flame make me want to punch a tree?
There was no reason to get jealous. No reason to get attached. This would end soon.
With either me finding Cormac. Or me leaving empty-handed.
Until then, Lyla was a lovely distraction, a balm over a wound I doubted would ever heal. A woman who needed an escape as much as I needed to forget. She was a miracle, really.
When she was in bed with me, I’d even managed a few decent nights of sleep.
This morning, it had been all too easy to drift back to sleep after she’d left for Eden Coffee, her scent lingering on the pillows.
When was the last time I’d slept past five? Years. Four, to be exact. Back when the world made sense, before everything got so fucked up, I used to love sleeping in.
That was before the dead haunted me in my dreams.
“What else happened with Winn yesterday?” Lyla’s question snapped me out of my head.
“What I told you last night. She basically said that I fucked up by coming here and not making her station my first stop.”
Lyla shot me an exaggerated frown over her shoulder. “Ouch.” “She’s not wrong. I broke protocol. She had a right to be pissed.” “But you’re still here.”
“I’m still here.” For another day. Another week. Maybe another month.
Lyla had only asked once how long I’d be in Quincy. I hadn’t answered because I wasn’t sure. I’d stay as long as possible, nothing more.
“Winn’s a good cop,” I said. “She’ll follow the rules. She’s a good sister-in-law too. Her hands are tied, mine aren’t. So I get to keep searching with the understanding that if I fuck up this investigation, she’ll castrate me.”
Lyla’s giggle filled the air. God, that sound. I hadn’t heard her laugh enough while I’d been in Quincy.
“I read about what Winn has done as chief in the newspaper,” I said. Lyla stopped, turning to face me. “Did you read about the shooting?” “I did. I’m sorry. That had to be hard on your family.”
“It was, especially Eloise. Winn too. I worry about her after what she had to do.” Lyla’s shoulders slumped. “Have you ever had to shoot
someone?”
“Twice.”
“Did they die?” “Once.”
Lyla’s eyes locked with mine, the sympathy in them so deep it made my chest feel too tight. She closed the distance between us, her hand splaying across my heart. “I’m sorry.”
“Me too.” I cupped her cheek, my thumb tracing the smooth line of her cheekbone.
Strange, but I hadn’t thought about that time in a while. I used to replay it daily.
Years ago, a hunter had called in a tip that he’d stumbled across a meth house in the mountains. I’d only been working with Cormac for about a year, and in those days, we’d done everything together. True partners. Friends. So the two of us had gone scouting to see if we could find the cabin. The plan had just been to scope it out, then call in for the local drug task force to take it down.
We’d found the place easily enough. It had been a shitty old hut, miles from any road or house. We’d stopped about fifty yards away, close enough for Cormac to pinpoint the place on GPS and take some photos.
He’d just dug his phone from a pocket when we’d heard a branch snap.
Then everything had happened in slow motion.
The guy who’d lived in that cabin had been out in the woods, doing whatever it was that meth addicts do. He’d seen us approach and had planned on killing us to keep his hideaway a secret. At least, that was what I assumed.
Had he not stepped on a branch, I’d probably be dead. Instead, that had given me enough warning to draw my gun and shoot him four times in the chest.
Cormac had been closer. He would have gotten hit first. But I’d saved his life.
Maybe that was where it had all gone wrong. Had I known what would happen, maybe I would have let that addict kill us both.
“Vance.” Lyla’s voice pulled me from the memory. She leaned her cheek into my palm.
I cleared my throat as I dropped my hand. “Winn seems solid. I don’t think you have cause to worry, but you should just ask her if she’s okay.
Chances are, she’ll say yes. Whether she means it or not. But just keep asking.”
“Is that what someone did for you? Kept asking if you were okay?” “Yes.”
“Who? Your family?” No, not my family.
Cormac.
And that was how he’d become my family.
But Lyla wouldn’t want that answer. It made Cormac too likable. Too good. So I did what I did best—changed the damn subject.
“Winn knows that we’re sleeping together, doesn’t she?”
Lyla blinked, taken off guard for a moment. But in our short time together, she’d already picked up that when I was done with a topic, I was done. So she nodded. “Yes, but I asked her to keep it between us.”
A secret. That had been my idea. So why did I hate it so much? “I’ve never kept a man secret before,” Lyla said. “It’s strange.” “I’m not asking you to keep a secret.”
“You’re leaving. I know the stakes here.”
The stakes. The fucking stakes. Yeah, I knew them too.
“I won’t lie to my family. Honestly, someone will figure it out anyway.
I’m surprised they haven’t yet.” “Why do you say that?”
“I have this habit of wearing my feelings like jewelry, bright and sparkly for the world to see. I trust people just because people can trust me. That’s how I was raised. That’s who I am. Lately, I just . . .” She let her gaze slide away, unfocused past my shoulder. “Don’t feel like myself.”
Of course she wouldn’t feel like herself.
“Hey.” I hooked my finger beneath her chin, tilting it up until her eyes came back to mine. “Are you okay?”
Tears filled her eyes. “Not really.”
My heart squeezed. Fucking Cormac. This was on him. These tears were on him. “What can I do?”
She sniffled, reaching up to dab the corner of her eyes. “Help me find this waterfall.”
If a waterfall was what she needed, then a waterfall was what we’d
find.
I took her by the shoulders, turning her around. Then I smacked her ass. Hard. “Lead the way, Blue.”
It didn’t earn me a laugh, but I’d keep trying to make her smile.
We hiked for another hour, mostly in silence. But whatever heaviness weighed on Lyla seemed to fade while her frustration mounted.
She stopped walking so quickly that I nearly plowed her over. “What?” I asked.
She huffed and tossed up her hands. “I’m lost.”
Was she? There was a faint noise in the distance. I’d heard it for the past few minutes, just assuming she had too.
“Shh,” I said.
She tensed. “Why?” “Listen.”
“To what?”
This woman. I clamped my hand over her mouth, earning a growl. Then with my free hand, I pulled off her beanie so she had nothing over her ears.
The moment she heard it, her gaze tipped up over her shoulder to meet mine. Those blue eyes lit up like stars.
Water.
She raced toward the sound, leaping over a fallen log as she jogged. I chuckled, shaking my head as I hurried to catch up.
Not a hundred feet away, past a cluster of bushes, the forest floor gave way to wet, black rocks, some spotted with moss. A stream trickled from a small pool fed from a gentle waterfall.
The current was slow. The cold weather was moving farther and farther down the mountains, and soon, this would be frozen. The waterfall itself was only four or five feet tall, but it was enough to fill the air with a steady rush of noise.
Lyla made her way along the slick rocks, her arms held out wide and ready to catch herself if her foot slipped.
I stayed back, watching as she navigated her way, inch by inch, around the pool’s perimeter. Then when she was close enough, she took off a glove, stretched out a hand and let it disappear into the waterfall.
There was the smile. White and wide, illuminating her whole face.
Fuck, but she was gorgeous. I couldn’t tear my eyes away, not even in a place like this, where nature was showing off. The cool, clear water. The
vivid green forest. It was a beautiful place, worthy of paintings or photographs.
But I couldn’t take my eyes off Lyla.
She dipped her fingers into the water, letting it play across her knuckles. After a moment, she pulled her hand out, probably due to the chill, and dried it on her jeans before quickly slipping her glove back on. Despite her careful approach to the water, she walked away with a determined stride.
“I found it,” she said, her smile lighting up her face as she came to stand beside me. “You found it.”
But then her smile faded. Her eyes welled up again, and she dabbed at the corners with practiced ease, catching the tears before they could fall.
“You okay?” I asked, knowing I’d be asking that question every day I was here.
She glanced around, her eyes taking in every detail. “Being here feels almost like stepping into a different lifetime. I feel like a completely different person from the girl who was here all those years ago.”
I couldn’t even recall who I was at that age—so much had changed since then.
“I’m glad we came,” she whispered. “But—”
She sighed. “But it’s hard to confront the reality that the life you’ve been building, the life you’ve worked towards day after day based on dreams you had when you were young, might not be the life you truly want. In a way, it feels like the girl who came here so long ago got it wrong.”
“Did she?”
Lyla shrugged. “I don’t know. Maybe. Partially. She’d probably argue with me. I miss the confidence I had. I miss the faith that it would all just . . . work out.”
The mental picture of seventeen-year-old Lyla was clear as day. Bright blue eyes, full of dreams.
I’d known another seventeen-year-old girl just like that once.
“I’m thirty,” Lyla said. “Somewhere along the way, I lost that girl. You’re good at finding people, right? Maybe after you catch Cormac, you could teach me your tricks.”
I stepped closer, so close that not even a breath of wind could come between us. Then I laid my hand on the center of her chest. “You don’t need me to find her. She’s right here. Where she’s always been.”
Lyla’s eyes searched mine like she couldn’t quite believe me. Then she fell forward, into my arms, burying her face in my chest. “Thanks.”
“Welcome.” I dropped a kiss to her hair, then let her go.
She took a few steps away, turning to face the waterfall again.
This was my chance to memorize this hidden paradise. To soak it all in. But again, all I could do was look at Lyla.
We were two sides to the same coin. Two people trying to find their way back to center.
Maybe it was too late for me to go back. But for Lyla, I wanted her to find a glimpse of that seventeen-year-old girl. To find the spark.
“We’d better get going,” I said. “I don’t want to get stuck out here in the dark.”
“Neither do I. And I’m starving.” “Want another granola bar?”
She held up a hand, stopping me from digging one from my backpack. “We’re getting cheeseburgers. Double cheeseburgers.”
I chuckled. “Double cheeseburgers. With fries.”
“Obviously.” She smiled, and when I offered her a hand, she held it tight, letting me guide her down the slippery rocks and back to the forest floor.
“We’ll follow the stream down for a bit,” I told her. “I’m guessing that will be faster. Then we’ll work our way back toward the trail.”
“Okay,” she said, staying close as we hiked.
It was always harder on the trip back, your muscles straining to keep balance with gravity working against you. I cut my normal stride in half, making sure she didn’t feel rushed.
Beside us, the stream trickled, growing wider, deeper the farther we worked down the mountain.
It wasn’t a river, not something you’d find on a map. But it was larger than I’d expected to find today. Maybe a good place for me to start tomorrow.
I was about to change course, head toward the trees and hike until we reached the path that would take us to the trailhead, when a yelp echoed behind me. I spun just in time to see Lyla’s feet sweep into the air.
And her land in the dirt with a thud.
“Lyla,” I gasped, rushing to her side and crouching down, my hands roaming over her body, searching for injury. “Are you hurt?”
“Ouch. No. I’m fine.” She tipped her head to the sky, drawing in a long breath, then surveyed the damage. “Shit.”
One side of her jeans was coated in the mud she’d slipped on.
She wiped at it but the only way that was coming out was in the wash. “I hate mud.”
“I’ve got a blanket in the truck. We’ll get back and peel you out of those wet jeans.”
“Why, Mr. Sutter.” Lyla fluttered her lashes. “Are you flirting with me?”
I chuckled, my heart sinking back down my throat.
It felt good to laugh, and Lyla had a way of coaxing it free. I’d laughed more in Quincy than I had in, well . . . four years.
I stood, offering her a hand to help her to her feet. “Come on.”
When she was standing, Lyla twisted to inspect the seat of her jeans— also coated in mud—then let out a string of curses that would make most guys on the force blush. When she looked to my face, she cocked her head to the side. “What?”
Except I wasn’t looking at her.
I was staring at the stream, just over her shoulder.
“Vance?” She followed my gaze to the water. “What? What are we looking at?”
“Stay here.” I passed her, taking slow, deliberate steps toward the water. I made sure every step was on a rock so my footprints wouldn’t show. Then I dropped to my haunches, peering through the clear stream.
And there, in its center, was a woven cone of willow branches. A fish trap.
“Fuck me.” I looked around, scanning the trees. My pulse thudded in my ears.
Not a fish trap anyone would buy, but one made. “Vance?” Lyla’s voice wobbled.
“Don’t move, Blue.” “Is it a bear?”
“You see that?” I pointed to the water. “It’s a fish trap.”
The outer cone had a wide end that tapered to a smaller hole. At the wide opening, another cone fit inside, shorter, with the same smaller hole. Fish could swim inside the cone—I couldn’t tell if there was bait inside
without pulling it from the water—and once they were in the cone, they’d get trapped, unable to find their way out of the smaller holes.
It was empty at the moment. Either because there weren’t any fish in this stream, or because someone had stopped by recently to put it in place.
“Son of a bitch,” I muttered, then stood and stepped away, taking as much care as I had earlier to step only on rocks as I made my way to Lyla.
There were footprints everywhere around where she’d slipped. Damn. “Do you think Cormac made that trap?” Lyla asked.
“Maybe.” I turned, looking up the mountain from where we’d come.
Part of me didn’t want to hope. The other part didn’t want to even consider this could be possible.
But that trap . . .
It had Cormac’s name written all over it. Whenever we’d go camping, he’d spend a night by the fire, weaving branches and reeds together for fun while the girls would roast marshmallows and make s’mores.
Maybe he had made this trap. Maybe he hadn’t left the area yet. Maybe I’d find that bastard after all.
