best counter
Search
Report & Feedback

Chapter no 23

Payback in Death

After sheโ€™d gathered what she needed, Eve met Peabody outside Interview B.

โ€œYou take him,โ€ Eve said, and handed Peabody the evidence box and files.

โ€œWhat? Me? Oh, you want me to soften him up, play good, caring cop so you can come in hard.โ€

โ€œNo. I want you to take him, hard, soft, however you need to take him.โ€ Eve opened the door. From the table, Robards looked up with red-

rimmed eyes.

โ€œRecord on. Dallas, Lieutenant Eve, and Peabody, Detective Delia, entering Interview with Robards, Denzel, on the matter of case files H- 6759, FA-12829, CM-4921, and related charges.โ€

Eve took a seat.

โ€œHave you been read your rights, Mr. Robards?โ€ Peabody asked. โ€œI donโ€™t know whatโ€™s going on. Iโ€”โ€

โ€œPlease answer the question.โ€ She snapped it out, whip sharp. โ€œYeah, they did that, butโ€”โ€

โ€œDo you understand your rights and obligations in these matters?โ€

โ€œI understand that, but I donโ€™t understand anything else. I need to talk to Elva. Nobody will let me talk to her.โ€

โ€œWe might be able to arrange that later.โ€ Peabody chose the brisk, all- business cop. โ€œRight now, you need to talk to us.โ€

Peabody opened a file. โ€œHow long have you known Elva Arnez?โ€ โ€œNineteen months. And two weeks,โ€ he added.

โ€œAnd how, in that amount of time, did she convince you to kill Captain Greenleaf and his son, Benjamin Greenleaf?โ€

โ€œSheโ€”howโ€”โ€ He pressed his lips together. Hugged his elbows. โ€œThatโ€™s crazy! Thatโ€™s just batshit. Sheโ€™d never, never do that. Elvaโ€™s a beautiful soul, aโ€”a tender heart.โ€

Peabody folded her hands over the file. โ€œAre you claiming you convinced her to murder these people?โ€

โ€œWe didnโ€™t kill anybody! I donโ€™t know howโ€”why,โ€ he corrected, โ€œyouโ€™d say something like that. We were friends with Martin and Ben.โ€

โ€œMakes it worse, doesnโ€™t it, Lieutenant? Even worse that these two shit stains would use friendship, a family that opened their homes to them, in order to kill.โ€

โ€œIt does. What do you figure, Detective? Two consecutive life terms, off- planet? They could actually end up with three.โ€

โ€œI figure the three. Either way, neither of them will ever get out of a cage. An off-planet cage.โ€

โ€œWe didnโ€™t do anything! Itโ€™s whacked, totally whacked you think we did.โ€

Obviously shaken, he leaned forward as if desperate to explain.

โ€œJesus, Elva wasnโ€™t even there when Martin died. Youย knowย that. And youโ€™re trying to say murder when it was suicide. Because he was a cop, like you. And Beth wonโ€™t get the insurance money if you say he killed himself. Weโ€™re sorry it happened, butโ€”โ€

He broke off, jolted when Peabody shoved to her feet. โ€œBullshit!โ€ She tossed crime scene printouts on the table. He winced, looked away.

โ€œWhat? Youโ€™re shy about looking at your handiwork? Canโ€™t look at the dead body of a man you called friend? You think we donโ€™t know what weโ€™re doing? You really think weโ€™re so stupid weโ€™d buy your half-assed setup?โ€

โ€œI donโ€™t know what youโ€™re talking about.โ€ A line of sweat dribbled down his left temple, and his gaze jumped everywhere except for the photos of the dead.

โ€œReally? Then Iโ€™ll walk your lying ass through it. Your Elva unlocked the bedroom window in yourย friendโ€™sย apartment. And when she gave you the all clearโ€”weโ€™ve got your โ€™links, assholeโ€”you went down the fire escape, went through the window. You walked through the apartment where youโ€™d been welcomed, put a stunner on high against yourย friendโ€™sย throat, and murdered him in cold blood.โ€

โ€œThatโ€™s crazy.โ€ And while sweat continued to roll, he began to shudder as if he sat in a brisk winter wind. โ€œYouโ€™ll never prove that because itโ€™s crazy. Martin killed himself. Itโ€™s sad, but itโ€™sโ€”โ€

โ€œYou put his fingers on the weapon, dropped it, just like Elva told you. But youโ€™re idiots who know squat about basic science and forensics. Look how clear these two prints are on the weapon.โ€

Peabody jabbed her finger on the crime scene shot.

โ€œNo prints to show heโ€™d handled the weapon, no prints to show heโ€™d checked or set the weapon on high. What, you think weโ€™d buy heโ€™d wiped the stunner clean before he used it?โ€

โ€œHeโ€”he must have. Heโ€”โ€

โ€œBullshit. Just two prints, so clear and pristine on the weapon? Couldnโ€™t be clear and pristine, physically impossible, with a self-termination.โ€

โ€œI donโ€™t understand whatโ€”โ€

โ€œDamn right you donโ€™t, even though you stood there and watched him convulse, you donโ€™t understand. Thatโ€™s why you fucked it up.

โ€œHow did it feel?โ€ she demanded. โ€œHow did it feel to jam that stunner against his throat, jam it hard, hold it there while his body convulsed? While you watched him die. How did it feel?โ€

Tears streamed to plop like rain on the table. โ€œNo. I didnโ€™t.โ€

โ€œYes, you did. You jammed that stunner so hard, held it there so the probes lacerated the skin. Did it seem quick to you, those few seconds it took?โ€

Squeezing his eyes shut, Robards shook his head.

โ€œAnd when his body stopped convulsing, you pressed his fingers to the weapon for those two clear, perfect prints, just like Elva told you. You wrote what sheโ€™d told you to write. Then you went back upstairs, signaled her it was done, just like she told you. You didnโ€™t know Detective Webster was coming, didnโ€™t know weโ€™d discover his body so quickly. You barely missed each other.โ€

She circled the table, stood behind him. โ€œEven that wouldnโ€™t have mattered because youโ€™reย stupid.โ€

โ€œAnd cruel,โ€ Eve murmured.

โ€œOh yeah, canโ€™t forget the cruel. You left him there for the woman whoโ€™d loved him for decades and decades to find. The woman whoโ€™d cooked for you, invited you to family dinners, holidays. You wanted to hurt her.โ€

Tears ran down his face, mixed with the sweat. โ€œI never wanted to hurt Beth!โ€

โ€œBut you had to, didnโ€™t you? You had to hurt Beth to give Elva what she wanted. I mean, hell, what choice did you have? But even that wasnโ€™t enough. You stood at the captainโ€™s memorial, pretending to feel griefโ€”you donโ€™t have feelings. And in his daughterโ€™s home, you used a childโ€”aย child

โ€”to try to kill his son.โ€

โ€œNo. No. You donโ€™t know that. Youโ€™re just making things up. Thatโ€™s what cops do.โ€

Peabody tossed a photo of the rope taken from the kitchen closet. โ€œWe found this in your apartment.โ€

โ€œIโ€”itโ€™s just some rope.โ€

โ€œItโ€™s cut from the rope used when you tried to hang Ben Greenleaf.โ€ โ€œItโ€™s not.โ€

โ€œIt is. Our lab verified.โ€ Not yet, Peabody thought, but they would. โ€œOh, and how about these? You had these in your closet.โ€

She set the two โ€™links on the table. โ€œIโ€ฆโ€

โ€œWhere did you get them?โ€

โ€œI just found them. I found them.โ€

โ€œReally, you found this one in Dory Greenleafโ€™s little purse, on the bar in the family room of her auntโ€™s house? And this one? You just happened to find that in her fatherโ€™s pocket before you put a noose around his neck?โ€

โ€œNo, no, I โ€ฆ found them on the street.โ€ โ€œWhen?โ€

โ€œYesterday, I think.โ€

โ€œYou think?โ€ she snapped out. โ€œYou think?โ€

โ€œYesterday!โ€ Terror in his eyes, he shouted it. โ€œI found them yesterday.โ€ โ€œWhen yesterday? Where exactly on the street?โ€

โ€œIโ€ฆโ€

โ€œQuick! Two disabled โ€™links that just happen to belong to the man you tried to murder and his daughter. Where, when, how?โ€

โ€œI donโ€™t know! I want to talk to Elva!โ€

โ€œYouโ€™re not going to talk to Elva. Maybe, just maybe, when sheโ€™s in the womenโ€™s lockup off-planet and youโ€™re in the menโ€™s, theyโ€™ll let you write love letters to each other.โ€

โ€œSheโ€™s not going to prison. You canโ€™t do that to her. You wonโ€™t!โ€

โ€œOh, yes. Yes, she is. Yes, we can and, yes, we will. She planned it all out, she told you just what to do, and you obeyed like a lovesick puppy. You did this for a woman who doesnโ€™t love you. She still loves the boy who died nearly ten years ago.โ€

โ€œThatโ€™s a lie!โ€ Fury burned through the tears, and the hands heโ€™d clutched together pounded on the table. โ€œYouโ€™re a liar, like all cops are liars. Weโ€™re going to get married. Weโ€™re going to make a family.โ€

โ€œNo conjugal visits between inmates off-planet. Tell us how it went down, Denzel. Maybe we can work it so you do the time on-planet, so your mother, your sisters can visit. Sheโ€™s going down, no way to change that.โ€

โ€œSheโ€™s not! She didnโ€™t do anything. Iโ€”I did it all. I killed Martinโ€” youโ€™re covering it up. Youโ€™re covering up everything he did to ruin her life. I hung Ben. I did it all. She had nothing to do with it. She didnโ€™t even know.โ€

โ€œIs that right? Howโ€™d you get the window open? Howโ€™d you manage to lift a hundred-and-eighty-five-pound unconscious man up to hang him? Whereโ€™d you get the service weapon?โ€

Tears still ran, but he folded his lips. โ€œI did what I did. Iโ€™m not saying anything else. I killed Martin and I tried to kill Ben. Elva wasnโ€™t part of it.โ€

โ€œYouโ€™re going to take the fall for a woman who doesnโ€™t love you. Who used you to do her dirty work.โ€

โ€œShe loves me. I saved her. Thatโ€™s all Iโ€™m going to say.โ€

โ€œYour white charger looks really tired, Denzel. Interview end.โ€ As he laid his head on the table and wept, they stepped out. โ€œGood work, mean-ass Peabody.โ€

Peabody rubbed at the back of her neck. โ€œI started feeling sorry for him

โ€”but I didnโ€™t let it stop me. Itโ€™s what you expected him to do.โ€

โ€œYeah. We can trip him up on the details later, because none of itโ€™s going to hold. Have him taken back down; have her brought up. Seriously, good work.โ€

โ€œThanks.โ€

Reo stepped out of Observation with Mira. โ€œA fool for love,โ€ she said.

โ€œAnd a killer with it.โ€

โ€œHe didnโ€™t plan any of it.โ€ Mira walked with Eve as she stared holes through a vending machine. โ€œHeโ€™s a follower. And he feels remorse.โ€

โ€œShe wonโ€™t. I donโ€™t trust this machine. Or any of them. Iโ€™m getting a cold drink from my AC.โ€

โ€œAllow me. Youโ€™re handing me a solid case on two cop killers. Whatโ€™ll it be?โ€ Reo asked.

โ€œPepsi.โ€

โ€œRemorse or notโ€โ€”Reo plugged in coinsโ€”โ€œheโ€™s going off-planet, and heโ€™ll never get out.โ€ She handed the tube to Eve.

โ€œThanks.โ€

โ€œPeabody kicked butt in there.โ€

โ€œSheโ€™s got it in her. Somebody like him though? It costs her some.โ€ She cracked the tube, drank deep.

โ€œYou, too,โ€ Mira said.

โ€œNo, doesnโ€™t cost me. Iโ€™m just tired of the whole fucking mess. Itโ€™s so senseless. A lot of them are, but this? Sheโ€™s spent nearly ten years of her life plotting and planning and calculating how to murder, to revenge a dirty cop and a boy who didnโ€™t love her. Any more than she loves the stupid fuck who killed for her.

โ€œI need to set up for Arnez.โ€

As she walked to her office, she pulled out her โ€™link.

โ€œWe have them,โ€ she said to Webster without preamble. โ€œYou made an arrest?โ€

โ€œTwo. Have one confessionโ€”half bullshit. Weโ€™re about to bring the second into Interview. If you want to observe, get here.โ€

โ€œWho?โ€

โ€œThe Greenleafsโ€™ friends and upstairs neighbors. I donโ€™t have time to brief you, Webster. Interview B, Observation. Hear it for yourself.โ€

She cut him off, and cooled her throat with Pepsi.

Sheโ€™d take a few minutes to collect herself, she thought. Just level off. Maybe, as usual, Mira had it right. Maybe the interview with Robards had cost herโ€”a little.

But mostly it infuriated her.

She could go into the box with Arnez pissed off. As long as the anger held well under the surface. The job wasnโ€™t about her feelings, but about law, about justice.

So sheโ€™d take a few minutes to collect herself, to drink the damn Pepsi, to stand at her window and look out at New York.

Street traffic snarled, and the airtrams glided by. Drivers, passengers heading home after the workday. Her work wasnโ€™t done, but when it was, sheโ€™d go home. And sheโ€™d shake it all off.

One more time.

She didnโ€™t hear him come, not when he moved, always, like the cat burglar heโ€™d been. But she sensed him as he stepped into her office.

He angled his head, those wild blue eyes on her face. โ€œYou donโ€™t look like a woman who was right all along and made two arrests.โ€

โ€œI am a woman who was right and made two arrests. Iโ€™ve got Arnez and her lawyer coming up to Interview. Iโ€™m finished with Robards.โ€

โ€œIโ€™m sorry I missed it.โ€

โ€œDonโ€™t be. Heโ€™s pathetic, pitiful. Heโ€™s an idiot.โ€ She set the tube down before she hurled it.

โ€œI had Peabody take him. She did good. She broke him.โ€ โ€œAll right.โ€

โ€œIt was all there. All of it.โ€ She walked to her comp when it signaled. โ€œIncluding this. Lab report on the rope we found in the goddamn kitchen closet of their apartment. Rope cut from the length they used to try to hang Ben Greenleaf. He had their โ€™linksโ€”Benโ€™s and his kidโ€™sโ€”in his closet. Not the bedroom, because that closetโ€™s all hers. The home office closet where he keeps his clothes, and pictures of his family because she doesnโ€™t want to see them.

โ€œAnd what does he do when Peabody breaks him? When tears are running down his face? He claims Arnez had nothing to do with it, no knowledge of it. He did it all on his own. Just him, in his shiny, blood- streaked armor.โ€

โ€œYou wonโ€™t let that stand.โ€

โ€œFucking A. Itโ€™s all her, just like that apartmentโ€™s all her. They live where she wanted, how she wanted. He can have his things, as long as she doesnโ€™t have to see them. She has a man who loves her enough to kill for her, and she uses that. You better believe she recognized that and exploited it. And she uses him to kill, to exact revenge for a dirty, corrupt cop who couldnโ€™t face the consequences, and a boy who decided heโ€™d rather blame everyone else and die.โ€

She shut her eyes. โ€œThe boy didnโ€™t have to die. Shouldnโ€™t have died. But nobody saw he was on the edge, not even the mother who loved him and was trying so hard to hold her family together.โ€

She opened eyes full of rage and pity. โ€œAnd Arnez, because she couldnโ€™t see past it, kept him on the edge with her drumbeat of payback. Her need to be the one the boy turned to, held on to.

โ€œThe boy didnโ€™t love her; the man she used to kill did. It didnโ€™t matter. Doesnโ€™t matter. Sheโ€™d let the man who loves her take the fall for her. I wonโ€™t.โ€

Saying nothing, Roarke stepped to her, put his arms around her. โ€œIโ€™m fine. Iโ€™m okay.โ€

โ€œYou will be.โ€

โ€œRobards loves her. Instead of saying, โ€˜Sorry, donโ€™t feel the same,โ€™ so he could move on, or building a real life with him, she uses him to get what she wants. What sheโ€™s wanted for almost ten years. Now heโ€™ll spend the rest of his life in a cage.โ€

โ€œYouโ€™ll see she does as well. Iโ€™ve no doubt youโ€™re right and she used and exploited his feelings for and about her. But he chose, Eve.โ€

โ€œHe chose.โ€ Nodding, she drew back. โ€œHis life, as he knew it, is over.

Now itโ€™s her turn.โ€

โ€œGo take her down, Lieutenant.โ€

She walked back to Interview B. โ€œReady, Peabody?โ€

โ€œReady. Her lawyerโ€™s Marcelle Congera. I did a quick search and sheโ€™s low-rent. Sheโ€™s handled some misdemeanorsโ€”public intoxication, disturbing the peace, and a bunch of civil suits. Nothing heavy.โ€

โ€œLetโ€™s make sure Arnez gets what she paid for.โ€ โ€œYou donโ€™t want me to take her.โ€

โ€œNot this time. Sheโ€™s mine.โ€

Eve opened the door. โ€œRecord on,โ€ she began, and read the details for the record before she sat.

If she felt a smug little thrill seeing Arnez in the orange jumpsuit, well โ€ฆ she could be petty.

The lawyer wore a pale blue suit. About forty, Eve judged, with a long, thin neck, her shoulder-length black hair swept back from a sharp-featured, disapproving face.

โ€œYou humiliated my client at her place of employment, an act that could cost her her position, and did so in your aggressive attempt to find a scapegoat over a retired police officerโ€™s death. We intend to pursue a civil suit.โ€

โ€œOh, well, in that case โ€ฆ Bring it. Your client will be pursuing her bullshit civil suit from a cage on Omega.โ€

โ€œDonโ€™t be ridiculous.โ€ Congera pursed her thin lips. โ€œI intend to file a motion of dismissal, all charges, and another for false arrest.โ€

โ€œFile all the motions you wantโ€”but Iโ€™d get a solid retainer before I did any work. Iโ€™ve got this feeling, Peabodyโ€”do you have this feeling?โ€”that Ms. Congeraโ€™s client hasnโ€™t been fully truthful and forthcoming with her legal representative.โ€

โ€œI share that feeling.โ€

โ€œFor instance,โ€ Eve said, โ€œI wonder if Ms. Congeraโ€™s client disclosed that she had a close connection to Louis Noy and his familyโ€”including his son, Brice. She sure as hell didnโ€™t disclose same when questioned after Captain Greenleafโ€™s murder.โ€

โ€œI fail to seeโ€”โ€

โ€œThen get your eyes fixed,โ€ Eve suggested. โ€œCaptain Greenleaf investigated Louis Noyโ€”formerly Captain Louis Noy of the NYPSDโ€”for corruption, extortion, witness and evidence tampering, among other things.โ€

โ€œThatโ€™s hardlyโ€”โ€

โ€œNot quite finished. Louis Noy killed himself, at his desk, in his home office, with his service weapon. Brice Noy, at nineteen, hanged himself. They remembered youโ€”Ellieโ€”Ella and Taylor Noy remembered you very well. Funny you didnโ€™t mention this connection.โ€

โ€œWhy would I? It was years ago. They were acquaintances. How would I possibly know Martin investigated Captain Noy? Why would I care?โ€

โ€œAcquaintances?โ€ She took out the prom photo, the preserved corsage.

โ€œTheyโ€™ve been through my things, my personal things.โ€ Fury rose red and hot over Arnezโ€™s cheeks. Her eyes blazed with it.

โ€œA duly executed search.โ€ Eve set the warrant on the table. โ€œAnd look here. You even kept the prom dress.โ€ Eve plopped the bagged dress on the table. โ€œAnd oh, hereโ€™s another thing.โ€ She took out the sealed โ€™link. โ€œTags and texts on this old model you kept in your treasure box.โ€

โ€œThose are my personal property. You have no right to my personal property.โ€ She rounded on Congera. โ€œFix this!โ€

โ€œA duly executed search,โ€ Eve repeated. โ€œTags and texts between you and Brice Noy. Intense tags and texts after his fatherโ€™s disgrace, after the suicide. You knew who Martin Greenleaf was when you moved into the building.โ€

Congera looked a bit off-balance, but she rallied. โ€œSouvenirs from nearly a decade ago are hardly evidence of a crime. Any more than my clientโ€™s acquaintance with someone Martin Greenleaf once investigated is evidence of a crime. Youโ€™ve overreached, Lieutenant.โ€

โ€œThey went through my things.โ€ Arnez pounded a hand on the table. โ€œDo something! Do your job.โ€

โ€œMs. Arnez.โ€ Congera patted her arm as if to soothe. โ€œThey had a warrant, but this? This means nothing. Mementos from your teenage years. Theyโ€™re reaching.โ€

โ€œYeah, we reached into that treasure box and found all these photos. Lots of themโ€”all of the Noy family. Nobody else but you and the Noy family. No other friends, no other families, teachers, pets, whatever. Just you and your โ€ฆ acquaintances.โ€

โ€œIf this is all you have, Lieutenant, Iโ€™ll go file my motion to dismiss.โ€

โ€œI wouldnโ€™t be too hasty,โ€ Eve warned as Congera started to rise. โ€œYou want something more current? Letโ€™s see what we have in our NYPSD treasure box. What do you think, Peabody?โ€

โ€œOh yeah.โ€ Peabody nodded when Eve took out the photos. โ€œThose are gold.โ€

โ€œI canโ€™t show you the actual ropes, as theyโ€™re on their way into Evidence from the lab. Got the lab report right here though. See this length of rope? Thatโ€™s the one used to hang Ben Greenleaf in his sisterโ€™s home at their fatherโ€™s memorial. And this one?โ€

Eve nudged them both over. โ€œThatโ€™s the rope we found in your clientโ€™s kitchen closet during our duly authorized search. As you see in the lab report, same rope, and the cuts on the end of each? Perfect match.โ€

โ€œIโ€™ve never seen that rope before. I wasnโ€™t even there when Ben was attacked.โ€

โ€œSure you were, because you attacked him. How about these?โ€ Eve took out the two โ€™links. โ€œThis one you took out of Benโ€™s pocket after you bashed

him in the head with his nieceโ€™s baseball trophy. And this one? His daughterโ€™s, the one you took from her purse and used to text him, as if from her, to lure him upstairs so you could kill him.โ€

โ€œThese are outrageous accusations.โ€ But Congera no longer looked convinced.

โ€œIโ€™ve never seen those โ€™links. Obviously they planted them. Fix this! You fix this or youโ€™re fired!โ€

โ€œWeโ€™re not Louis Noy,โ€ Eve snapped. โ€œThe dirty cop you made into a hero, a daddy substitute. And you were there. You shut down the security, stole the kidโ€™s โ€™link, said your goodbyes before you slipped upstairs. Texted Ben, knocked him unconscious from behind, and, while he was out, put the noose around his neck, left him hanging. You went out through the master bedroom, the terrace doors, and out through the side gate.

โ€œThe trouble?โ€ Eve continued. โ€œWebster, again. He went up to check on Ben, found him, saved his life.โ€

โ€œI was nowhere near Carlieโ€™s house when Ben was attacked. Denzel will swear to that.โ€

โ€œWellโ€ฆโ€ Eve shrugged. โ€œHe had his chance, didnโ€™t. We already interviewed him.โ€

โ€œThen heโ€™sย lying! Lying to protect himself. If heโ€™s done these horrible things, itโ€™s not my fault.โ€

โ€œHuh. If heโ€™s lying and he tried to kill Ben, how could he have done it alone if you were together?โ€

Arnezโ€™s eyes flicked once before she dug in. โ€œAfter we left the memorial, Denzel told me to go on home, that he had to run a few errands. I had a terrible headache, so I went home, took a sleeping pill.โ€

Sheโ€™d bury him without a secondโ€™s hesitation, Eve thought. Because itโ€™s all about her.

โ€œI wonder why the security cams at your apartment building donโ€™t show you coming home alone. I wonder why they show both you and Robards entering the building, together, less than thirty minutes after Ben was attacked.โ€

โ€œIโ€”I meant I took a walk to try to clear my head.โ€ Casting her eyes down, she rubbed her temple. โ€œItโ€™s been a terrible few days. I took a walk, and Denzel caught up with me. Then I went in, took the pill.โ€

โ€œSo, somehow he doubled backโ€”on his ownโ€”went back into the house, set Ben up, bashed him, then managedโ€”on his ownโ€”to haul a hundred- and-eighty-five-pound unconscious man a foot off the ground. Then he left, and miraculously ran into you in time for the two of you to enter the apartment building together.โ€

โ€œIโ€™m not saying he did any of that. Iโ€™m saying I didnโ€™t. I certainly didnโ€™t kill Martin. I was with Beth and the others.โ€

โ€œItโ€™s interesting, I think, that ninety-eight seconds after security shows you leaving the building on the night of Martin Greenleafโ€™s murder, you texted Robards.ย All clear, you texted. We have your โ€™links, too.โ€

โ€œSo what? Just letting him know we were on our way to the bar.โ€

โ€œRight. And also interesting, some seven minutes after time of death, Robards texted you.ย Itโ€™s done.ย You answered with a heart emoji.โ€

โ€œI โ€ฆ Iโ€™d asked him to tidy up. Heโ€™d left a mess, and I was annoyed. He just wanted me to know heโ€™d done that.โ€

โ€œObviously, my client has already proven she was elsewhere when Captain Greenleaf was killed. Thereforeโ€”โ€

โ€œYou unlocked the window. You know Bethโ€™s habitsโ€”youโ€™ve made a point to. Into the bedroom, and sheโ€™s fussing with shoes. Unlock the window with access to the fire escape. You text the all clear. Robards texts you itโ€™s done.โ€

โ€œYou canโ€™t prove any of that. Itโ€™s absurd.โ€

โ€œYou used one of Noyโ€™s drop weapons. Did he give it to youโ€”for protection maybeโ€”the way he slipped you money now and again? Men like him like to buy loyalty. He sure bought yours.โ€

โ€œSay nothing, Ms. Arnez. Lieutenant, I want to consult with my client.โ€ โ€œHe never loved you. Brice never loved you.โ€

Eve said it quietly, and saw it hit home.

โ€œHe didnโ€™t keep a box with photos of you, of mementos to take out and look at, and think of you. He brought you home because he felt sorry for youโ€”โ€

โ€œLiar. Liar.โ€

โ€œHe liked people, liked being with them, helping them. He liked girls. He didnโ€™t like you the way he liked other girlsโ€”so many of them. You mustโ€™ve hated them, the girls he spent time with instead of spending it with you.โ€

โ€œYou donโ€™t know anything about it.โ€

โ€œI think I do. He took you to the prom.โ€ Eve laid a hand on the dress. โ€œAnd told his sister he was taking you because you didnโ€™t have any friends. A pity date.โ€

โ€œThatโ€™s a lie.โ€ She hissed it out. โ€œYou didnโ€™t know Brice. You donโ€™t know anything about him.โ€

โ€œIโ€™ve been getting to know the boy he was, so handsome, so bright. Kind. A boy from a happy family with a father at the head of it. You wanted him, wanted that family, that father. So you stuck, you had a goal. Brice was the goal.โ€

โ€œLieutenant,โ€ Congera interrupted. โ€œThis is pure speculation.โ€

โ€œConclusions based on evidence. You inserted yourself into his family to achieve that goalโ€”and maybe found something in Noy you didnโ€™t have. That daddy figure. You inserted yourself into the Greenleaf family because you had a goal. Kill Captain Greenleaf, make it look like suicide, mirror your hero. Pay Greenleaf back. Not finished yet. Kill the son, mirror the boy you loved, pay them all back.

โ€œKill a good man, try to kill his son, all in memory of a boy who never loved you. He just felt sorry for you.โ€

โ€œHeย didย love me! You knowย nothing. Brice loved me. We were soul mates. We were going to get married, have a family. He wasย everythingย to me.โ€

Sitting back, Eve smiled. โ€œThat sounds like a lot more than an acquaintance.โ€

โ€œMs. Arnezโ€”Elvaโ€”please donโ€™t say anything else. Let meโ€”โ€ Arnez smacked Congeraโ€™s hand away.

โ€œSheโ€™s not going to get away with saying those lies. Martin Greenleaf destroyed the best man I ever knew. He destroyed myย family! He killed the only one Iโ€™ll ever love. And for what? For what? For his rules, his regulations, his righteous line of right and wrong? Why should he have a life? Why should he have a happy family? Where is mine?โ€

โ€œYou used one of Noyโ€™s drop weapons. Did he give it to you or did you take it?โ€

โ€œI took it. Why shouldnโ€™t I have something? His wife, his daughter, all they could do was cry. They wereย ashamedย of Louis. Ashamed. I stood up for him. Brice and I stood up for him. I was more a daughter to him than

that sniveling little brat. And his wife? Saint fucking Ella? She just forgets him, forgets him and her own son? Marries someone else. They can go to hell, just like Greenleaf.โ€

โ€œYou planned it all out, the timing, the method. Did Denzel help with that?โ€

โ€œDenzel canโ€™t plan his way out of a grease-soaked job in someone elseโ€™s garage. I gave my father and the man I love justice.โ€

It was all there, Eve thought, all there in that striking face. The fury, the hate, all the bitter years of them.

โ€œStep one, get an apartment in the building. Step two, become friends. That leads to step three, get to know the family, earn their affection and trust, learn their routines. It really pissed you off when Ella Noy married Cal Rosen. She didnโ€™t even invite you to the wedding.โ€

โ€œAs if Iโ€™d have gone. Love is forever. She disgraced herself and the memory of her husband, her son. I thought better of her. I was wrong. She tossed them aside. Well, I didnโ€™t.โ€

โ€œHow did you talk Denzel into going along with murder?โ€

โ€œNot murder. Justice. He understands what Martin did, how he destroyed my family. Heโ€™ll do anything for me.โ€

โ€œIโ€™m withdrawing as counsel for Ms. Arnez. Ms. Arnez, I advise you to remain silent and consult another attorney immediately.โ€

โ€œOh, fuck you. You had one job and couldnโ€™t do it.โ€

โ€œFormer counsel for Ms. Arnez exiting Interview,โ€ Eve said. โ€œYouโ€™re entitled to legal representation.โ€

โ€œAnd Iโ€™ll do better next time. Much better. I did what needed to be done, and Iโ€™ll find a lawyer whoโ€™ll make that clear. Louis and Brice would be proud of me.โ€

Weโ€™ll play that tune, Eve thought.

โ€œIโ€™m sure Louis Noy would be proud, proud of how well you planned it out. You chose a night youโ€™d have an unassailable alibi,โ€ Eve began. โ€œYou unlocked the bedroom window to give Robards, your partner, access to Captain Greenleafโ€™s apartment.โ€

โ€œYes, yes, yes.โ€

โ€œWhen you sent the all clear, Robards entered by that unlocked window via the fire escape. He used the weapon youโ€™d taken from Noy after Noyโ€™s death, and killed Martin Greenleaf. He left the drop piece, after putting the

captainโ€™s prints on it, wrote the suicide note, and exited by the same window.โ€

โ€œThis is boring,โ€ Arnez decided.

โ€œWonโ€™t take much longer. The glitch in the plan. Detective Webster, who arrived shortly after, and brought me into it. And weโ€™re there when you return with the widow. You canโ€™t get back into the bedroom and lock the window.โ€

โ€œIt was perfect. It shouldโ€™ve been perfect. It didnโ€™t matter about the damn lock. I wasnโ€™t there.โ€

โ€œSince the suicide plan didnโ€™t work, you felt you needed to move on Ben quickly. Is that right?โ€

โ€œWhy wait? Letโ€™s not waste time now, either. Denzel shut down the security. I got the little bratโ€™s โ€™link, sent the whiny text after we got upstairs. Daddy came right along. Bang on the headโ€”that was my pleasure. String the asshole up, go outโ€”you figured out how. That shouldโ€™ve worked, too. He should be dead, like my Brice.โ€

โ€œThe rope, the โ€™links?โ€

โ€œOversights. We werenโ€™t suspects, should never have been looked at twice. How did you connect me to Louis and Brice?โ€

โ€œWeโ€™re cops. We do our job.โ€

โ€œCaptain Louis Noy was a cop, and wouldโ€™ve crushed you like a bug.โ€

Now Eve smiled. โ€œYouโ€™re welcome to think so. Maybe itโ€™ll get you through the first few decades in an off-planet cage.โ€

โ€œI levied justice for two good men. My father and my lover. No one whoโ€™s ever loved would convict me.โ€

โ€œHereโ€™s a media bulletin,โ€ Eve said as she rose. โ€œNoy was neither a good man nor your father. The subject has confessed on record, all charges. Have her taken down, Peabody. Sheโ€™s entitled to other legal representation if she chooses. Interview End.โ€

As she walked to the door, Eve glanced back. Yeah, she thought. She could be petty.

โ€œI bet Brice Noy never banged you. Not even a pity bang.โ€ Arnez looked at her with dead eyes. โ€œIโ€™ll kill you one day.โ€

โ€œYou go right ahead and believe that. Maybe itโ€™ll get you through the decades after the first few.โ€

You'll Also Like